Postmates vs Doordash: Benefits, Pay, Requirements [2022]

Last Updated on 6 months by Anoob P

In this post, we are doing an in-depth comparison of Postmates vs Doordash including Benefits, Pay and Requirements to join these platforms.

I have also written a detailed post about Delivery Drivers Inc Reviews, Pros, Cons & How to Make Money–you can read it if you are interested.

You can also read our Roadie app review if you want to know more about Roadie delivery app.

After working full-time for more than 12 years, I switched to working for myself and trying to earn a living online.

If you are uncertain about your future, then you can read my post about What The Future Holds or Finding Excitement in Life–you may find it interesting.

If you are interested in the whole concept of making money online, you can check out some of my other posts including 10 Easy Ways to Earn Money Online without Investment, How to Earn Money from YouTube, how to earn money from Facebook and how to start a blog and make money.

I recently helped a client of mine generate $1000 in income from his YouTube channel that was not making any money and even you can do the same.

Earlier, I had co-founded a video company and raised $2 million in funding and then got fired from the company I started. I had done lot of testing and research on how to monetize YouTube and now I use the same skills to help other YouTubers.

You can read my full story here if you are interested.

I have also written a detailed post about How to Start an Online Business That Changes Your Life (without Luck) & lessons in entrepreneurship I learnt the hard way–you can read it if you have the time.

Postmates vs Doordash Comparison: Benefits, Pay, Requirements [2022]

What is Postmates?

Postmates is a delivery app that not only caters to food and beverages but also a variety of retail items.

They aim to deliver anything on demand.

They source items locally and help small businesses grow. You can download their app and place an order and it will directly be delivered to your place of convenience. 

Official website of Postmates: https://postmates.com/

What is DoorDash?

DoorDash is an on-demand food and beverage delivery service that brings you your favourite dishes to your doorsteps.

Those who want to become couriers can use the dasher app and deliver according to their own schedule.

Official website of DoorDash: https://www.doordash.com/

Postmates vs DoorDash Pay Scale

Pay for DoorDash

The pay for Dashers is calculated based on three things. They are:

Base pay– Base pay is the minimum amount that you will earn no matter the distance or order. The base pay is based on time, distance and desirability. It ranges from $2-$10 depending on the order. DoorDash tells you right off the bat how much money you are going to make for the number of miles you are going to drive. 

Promotions– This includes peak pay and challenges. Peak pay is essential when a certain locality or area is witnessing a high number of orders. These areas will need more dashers on priority. Such areas will have a red light blinking besides them in the dasher app. Every delivery you make in these areas will earn you extra dollars. The amount of additional money you make is also specified. 

Challenges– This is an interesting feature that earn you extra money if you complete a certain number of deliveries in the stipulated time. 

Apart from that you also get 100% of the tips you earn.

You stand a chance to make about $500 per week on DoorDash if you deliver about 3 to 4 hours every day on DoorDash.

When it comes to Postmates vs Doordash in payscale, DoorDash is a winner.

Pay for Postmates

Postmates has a lower base pay than DoorDash and drivers are paid according to the minutes spent in the store and the kind of orders that are placed. 

The area that you are delivering to also matters, high demand areas are called hot spots and offer more money.

Orders that have a high-payout rate are called Blitz Pricing. Peak hours are beneficial as you get paid much higher than you normally would. 

Postmates gives you a $3 pay plus tip but you don’t know if you’re gonna get tipped especially for lower end restaurants you’re not going to make very much money. 

Postmates doesn’t tell you the total amount of miles you would have to drive . You can get an estimate because they’ll give you the pinpoints on the map so you know where you’re going to go but you don’t really have accurate details.

With postmates you can make $5 on a ten-mile order plus whatever tip you get. 

Other ways to earn money on Postmates includes referring the ap to your friends. Each time anyone sign up using your referral code you get a reward. 

You also get a bonus if you complete a certain amount of deliveries in the stipulated time. 

In the comparison of Postmates vs Doordash payment, Doordash is slightly better.

Postmates vs DoorDash Requirements

When it comes to requirements, Postmates vs Doordash has similar requirements. Even though the line of work is similar, Postmates requires drivers to deliver all kinds of packages.

Postmates Requirements

These are the requirements to join Postmates as a delivery executive.

For being a Postmates courier you have to be 18 years or older

The most important requirement is that of a smartphone. You should be able to download the Postmates Fleet app that is used to make deliveries. 

You also require a valid driving licence and car insurance if you are going to drive a car for delivering

A background check will be conducted on you and you should pass it

You might also have to give an interview.

DoorDash Requirements

These are the requirements to join Doordash as a delivery executive.

You must be 18 years or older.

You must own a smartphone so that you can download and use the Dasher app for couriers

You must have access to a vehicle. This can be a car, scooter or even a bicycle in certain cities

If you are planning to drive a car or scooter you will have to pass a DMV background check

You also require a valid driving licence and car insurance 

So as you can see Postmates vs Doordash delivery executive requirements are similar.

Postmates vs. DoorDash: Delivery hours

In this section, we are goin to look at delivery hours and how Postmates vs Doordash fares in both.

For postmates you can be logged in at any time and can make money 24/7 whereas for DoorDash you actually have to go and get your shifts. 

You will earn more during rush hours and it gives you flexibility to work according to your availability.

However this can work both ways as you could just be sitting around and not get many orders because of the sheer number of people logged in. 

For DoorDash you can plan out your deliveries according to your schedule by booking them in advance. You can schedule deliveries almost a week in advance. 

You can use the Dash now option in areas that have lots of orders coming in. These areas will light up in red or pink in the app and pay your more than the regular amount. 

When it comes to Postmates vs Doordash delivery timings, Doordash is better because there is rush hour and you can earn more during these hours.

DoorDash vs. Postmates: Driver ratings

In this section, we are going to look at Postmates vs Doordash driver ratings.

Postmates earlier had a five-star rating system which has now changed to a thumbs up and down rating.

Postmates claims that the reason behind this shift is so that the drivers are not held accountable for things that are beyond their control.

Hence they switched to a system that shows their satisfaction or dissatisfaction with the overall experience while using the app.

The drivers are not held accountable for problems regarding the food. And the rating doesn’t affect your presence on the app.

DoorDash has a five-star rating system based on the following factors:

Customer rating: Customers rate your service on a scale of one to five stars. You need an average rating of 4.2 or your account might be suspended. This is dependent on your demeanor towards the customer and your handling of the package. 

Completion rate: This is the number of deliveries that you have successfully completed. DoorDash looks at your most recent 100 in rotation and you have to have at least a 70% rating if you want to continue on the app.

Acceptance rate: This rate determines the number of deliveries you have made or accepted. There is no minimum or average rating required here. 

On time / early rate: You will get a higher rating if you deliver the order on or before time. 100 of your latest ratings are counted for this. This rating determines your performance and your delivery speed.

DoorDash vs. Postmates: Deductions

In this section, we are going to look at Postmates vs Doordash deductions which is a very important factor to consider before joining either platforms.

Whether its DoorDash or Postmates you will be liable to pay your own taxes. But there are few deductions that you are eligible for. These include:

• Mileage
• Car insurance
• Tolls and parking
• Personal phone and phone plan
• Accounting costs

DoorDash vs. Postmates Final Verdict

You can not solely rely on these delivery apps for your income, they would work better as a side-hustle to earn something extra.

When choosing an app it depends on what app is more used in your area so that you can earn more through multiple deliveries.

DoorDash is better when it comes to base pay and it also pays you according to the miles you cover. DoorDash tells you exactly how much you are going to make before for each delivery while you are choosing your orders.

On top of that you can get tipped even more so just off the bat DoorDash is a good way to make money.

However Postmates gives you the option of logging in anytime so you can make more during peak hours.

In the end you can try out both and decide which app suits you better. 

Frequently Asked Questions about DoorDash vs. Postmates

Does DoorDash pay better than Postmates?

According to reports from users of both apps, Postmates tend to pay slightly more than Doordash.

How is DoorDash different than Postmates?

Doordash delivery is only for food whereas Postmates can delivery all types of package.

Is Postmates or DoorDash more popular?

Both apps are popular but the number of orders will depend on the location.

How do door dashers get paid?

Door Dash delivery executives get paid for each delivery and get to keep thier tips. Door dashers are paid via direct bank transfer.

Can you make a living off of Postmates?

On an average, you can make $18-$25 per hour on Postmates but your income will not be stable so it is difficult to make a living off of Postmates.

Do I have to put DoorDash on my taxes?

DoorDash works as an independant contractor, so all drivers are required to take care of taxes including filing returns with IRS.

Recommended Reads

6 Free & Best Chequing Account Canada Banks Can Offer You in 2022

10 Easy Ways to Make Money Online in Canada

Instant Approval Credit Cards for Bad Credit in Canada

How to Write a Cheque in Canada: A Step-by-Step Guide

Lending Loop Review: Pros, Cons & Fees of Peer-to-Peer Lending in Canada in 2022

10 Easy Ways to Make Money Online in Canada

Side Hustles to Help You Make Money Online

How to Earn Money from YouTube [Step By Step Guide]

10 Easy Ways to Earn Money Online

How to Earn Money from Facebook [Step By Step Guide]

Best Work from Home Jobs to Earn Money Online

12 Best Paying Entry Level Work from Home Jobs That Require No Special Qualifications

How to Start Blogging and Make Money